Clay County stands to lose $40 million in property tax revenue next year and $70 million the year after, according to figures county officials presented Oct. 27.
Amendment 3, the homestead exemption expansion Florida voters approved Nov. 3 with 62% of the vote, will raise the non-school homestead exemption from $50,000 to $150,000 in 2027 and to $250,000 in 2028, according to the Jacksonville Daily Record. School taxes are not affected. Property taxes that fund county services are.
The amendment hits Clay County harder than most. Property Appraiser Tracy Drake told the Board of County Commissioners at its Oct. 27 meeting that Clay will be the second-most-impacted county in the state, behind only St. Lucie County, Clay Today reported. The county faces a 33.23% revenue loss, well above the statewide average of 20.34%, Drake said.
"This vote will fundamentally change the tax system in the state of Florida," Drake said.
That revenue loss lands on top of a projected $44.5 million General Fund deficit that county staff disclosed at a June 9 budget workshop, according to ClayViews. County officials have said that deficit does not yet factor in any Amendment 3 impact.
What cuts could look like
At the Oct. 27 meeting, several county departments presented reduced budgets under a scenario splitting cuts evenly between public safety and other services, Clay Today reported.
Sheriff Michelle Cook said a 15% budget reduction would mean losing $18 million, 77 sworn deputies and 56 support staff. Response times would grow longer. K-9 units, the narcotics unit, the marine unit and community programs would face elimination. A 30% cut would require eliminating a third of the workforce, Cook said.
Fire Rescue could lose up to 88 firefighters and 24 units. The county would also have to stop billing for ambulance service and outsource EMS transport, increasing costs for residents, according to Clay Today.
Supervisor of Elections Chris Chambless said a 15% cut would close the Thrasher-Horne and Oakleaf early voting sites, eliminate part-time staff and sample ballots, and reduce early voting days and hours to the state minimum.
"The history of no lines in Clay County will be just that, history," Chambless said.
Clerk of Court Tara Green said a 15% reduction would mean $589,000 in cuts, including the closure of the Orange Park branch office. Library hours would shrink and one library branch would close.
Budget strain predates the amendment
Clay County's fiscal pressure started before Amendment 3. The county proposed raising its Public Service Utility Tax from 4% to 10% in June 2025 to fund public safety shortfalls, according to ClayViews. The Board rejected the increase 4-1 on July 8, 2025.
Commissioner Alexandra Compere called it a short-term fix at the time. The county's total budget grew from $399 million in 2022 to an estimated $571 million in 2026, a 43% increase over five years, according to ClayViews.
What happens in Tallahassee
Gov. Ron DeSantis said Nov. 4 he wants a special legislative session before Jan. 1, 2027, to implement a "taxpayer bill of rights" and prevent local governments "from doing an end-run around the amendment and taxing them in other ways," the Florida Phoenix reported.
DeSantis also said he wants to create a fund for smaller counties to cover core needs.
Incoming legislative leaders were less certain about the timeline. Senate President-Designate Jim Boyd said on a podcast recorded before the election that implementation "can wait until we reconvene in January," according to the Florida Phoenix. House Speaker-Designate Sam Garrison, who represents Clay County, called Amendment 3 "a very, very complicated issue" and said he would "rather be right than be quick."
The county said at its Oct. 27 meeting that staff would return to the Board within two weeks of the amendment's passage to begin finalizing a plan. No follow-up meeting has been confirmed in available records as of Nov. 10.

.jpg)




